Tamiflu Efficacy, Safety in Doubt, Says BMJ
Nov 14, 2012
The British Medical Journal
) has al eged that pharmaceutical
giant Roche is deliberately hiding clinical trial data about the
efficacy of oseltamivir ( Tamiflu
) in patients with influenza. The
journal says global stockpiling and routine use of the drug are not
supported by solid evidence and al eges that Roche concealed
neurological and psychiatric adverse events associated with the
neuraminidase inhibitor drug.
In an open letter from Fiona Godlee, MD, editor-in-chief of BMJ
Professor John Bel , FRS, HonFREng, PMedSci, Regius Professor
of Medicine at Oxford University in the United Kingdom and a
Roche board member, October 29, Dr. Godlee
reminds Bel of concerns that werereliability of Tamiflu research.
At that time, BMJ
published an updated Cochrane review of
neuraminidase inhibitors in healthy adults. That study "took the
view that, since eight of the 10 [randomized control ed trials] on
which effectiveness claims were based, were never published, and
because the only two that had been published were funded by
Roche and authored by Roche employees and Roche-paid external
experts, the evidence could not be relied upon," Dr. Godlee writes.
Roche promised to make complete clinical trial data available, but
Cochrane researchers and BMJ
claim the company has not done
so. In her letter to Roche, Dr. Godlee explained that each clinical
trial report typical y consists of 5 modules, but only module 1 has
been provided for each trial."What Has Roche Got to Hide?"
In January 2012, the Cochrane Library an updated review that included unpublished data and revealed inconsistencies
and incomplete data. In her open letter to Roche, Dr. Godlee explained, "The Cochrane reviewers now know that there are at least 123 trials of Tamiflu and that the majority (60%) of patient data from Roche Phase 3 completed treatment trials remain unpublished. There are concerns on a number of fronts: the likely overstating of effectiveness and the apparent under-reporting of potential y serious adverse effects. Meanwhile, Tamiflu has just been added to the list of essential drugs alongside aspirin and beta blockers."
In an editorial October 29 in BMJ
, Dr. Godlee asks, "What has Roche got to hide?"
However, in a responding to Dr. Godlee's open letter in October 2012, Roche denies withholding clinical data.
When questioned by Medscape Medical News
about whether any physician or researcher has been given al 5 modules from the 10 clinical trials requested by the Cochrane researchers, and where those data are located currently, Roche responded with a statement much like its previously published statement. Roche said it had provided the Cochrane researchers "with access to 3200 pages of very detailed information, enabling their questions to be answered."
The statement added that al completed Roche Tamiflu research results are available in peer-reviewed journals or summarized on their Web site. "More detailed clinical trial reports.are available for use by investigators on a password-protected site, enabling researchers to verify the findings of these studies," according to the company's statement.
"Roche has made ful clinical study data available to health authorities around the world, according to their various requirements, for their review as part of the licensing process. It is the role of global health authorities to review detailed information on medicines when assessing benefit/risk," said the Roche response
"Within the scope of a signed agreement Professors Lipsitch and Hernan [from Harvard University] received the 10 studies cited in Kaiser et al," the statement to Medscape Medical News
Open Data Campaign
Hoping to prevent similar issues in the future, BMJ
is instituting a requiring pharmaceutical companies that sponsor clinical trials to commit to making relevant anonymized patient-level data available to physicians, scientists, and others who reasonably request it as a precondition for publication.
"We wil require authors of trials of drugs and devices to commit to making their data available on reasonable request," said Dr. Godlee in an email interview with Medscape Medical News
. "We cannot police this ourselves, but we wil encourage researchers whose requests for access are declined to send rapid responses to the BMJ
saying what they asked for and why it was declined. We wil then ask the authors to account for their decision not to release the data," Dr. Godlee explained.
"This is part of a journey and by no means the last step on the road. I expect that our next step, when data deposition systems are better developed and accepted, wil be to ask authors to deposit their data on submission of their article," Dr. Godlee said. "[W]e wil want to extend this to trials in other areas and to other types of study design. We also hope that other journals wil move in the same direction," Dr. Godlee added.
has not given up on its efforts to obtain complete clinical trial data from research on oseltamivir. In its first open data campaign, BMJ
is making public al correspondence between the journal, Roche, the World Health Organization, and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
"I hope very much that the BMJ
's campaign wil succeed in making
the ful data on oseltamivir available to the Cochrane reviewers, so they can give governments around the world the true picture of this drug's effectiveness and safety," Dr. Godlee said.
"Regulators, research ethics committees, and bodies like [the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excel ence] who decide which drugs wil be bought by governments or reimbursed by health insurers also have a key role in pushing for access and independent scrutiny of the data," Dr. Godlee explained.
Dr. Godlee has disclosed no relevant financial relationships.
. Published online October 29, 2012.,
"Reactive statement - BMJ open letter." Roche.
Medscape Medical News 2012 WebMD, LLC
Cite this article: Tamiflu Efficacy, Safety in Doubt, Says BMJ. Medscape
. Nov 14, 2012.
Welcome-So very glad to be here! It’s hard to believe that it has been almost a year since I have been with you all! I miss my daily visits to the City working with Sherry and our monthly coalition meetings together. Do know, I think of you all often and I am always ready to answer any questions Brooke or Natalie may have! My family looks back on our time with SCHEC with great memories. I will U
SAFETY DATA SHEET: ZEOSOFTTM NATURAL HOUSEHOLD STAINLESS Safety Data Sheet Issued 28th December 2012 Section 1: Product and Company Identification Product Name ZEOSOFTTM NATURAL HOUSEHOLD STAINLESS STEEL CLEANER contains a soft zeolite / soft silica minerals compound from the Rotorua region of New Zealand, formed from fine volcanic ash by hot geothermal springs. Cleans, absorbs, deodo